Shutter Island Analysis (2022)

Leonardo Dicaprio of Shutter Island

Shutter Island is an American Psychological Film that expresses a lot of disorder and dissociative identities disorders, especially from the main character of the movie, Leonardo DiCaprio. The movie is a reflection of the Dennis Lehane’s novel of 2003, which was later produced as a non-noir psychological thriller. It was directed by Martin Scorsese. The gist of the movie is the investigation of a psychiatric facility on Shutter Island after a patient disappears. This discussion will, therefore, focus on the analysis of the main character, Leonardo who suffers from a lot of disorders.

In the movie, Leonardo DiCaprio begins as a marshal of the United States of America, where he investigates a psychiatric facility of Shutter Island primarily due to the disappearance of the one patient Rachel Solando. She was incarcerated for the act of drowning her three children. What leads Leonardo to her is the note found in her room. Their journey is delayed for three days on the Island due to the massive storm that affects the movement to the mainland. A controversy arises when Leonardo finds the doctor who was caring for Rachel also absent for a vacation, especially after the disappearance of the Solando. This creates a discussion, making them demand a full access in the hospital, and being warned against accessing ward C. however, as the investigation goes on, a patient writes to Leonardo Warning him to run.

The Movie is based on a psychiatric experiment that takes place in the island, unknown to government authorities as well as the most people working in the island it is for that reason why Rachel is infected to prevent her from revealing the illegal experiment to the government agencies. Leonardo, being a government agency that might investigate and reveal the secrets of the island, the management had to do all things possible to prevent that from happening. Therefore, the investigation of the disorders and deactivation disorders are consequently conducted to help in the completion of the experiment

(Video) Shutter Island: Why Perspective is Everything

Dissociative identity disorder is one of the diseases that Leonardo suffers from. This condition is characterized by possessing different identities. Recalling for essential episodes of one’s life being among the most common symptoms of the DID. According to the movie, Leonardo finds it challenging to remember where he left his partner Aula, mainly when he wanted to access the restricted room by claiming the Clift and the partner are separated from him. An analysis of the investigation of the Shutter Islands which he conducts also is characterized by a mix-up of information, especially the explanation of how Rachel ends up in the facility as a patient rather than a doctor.

During their investigation as well Leonardo sees the body of Aula on the rock. When he gets down, the organization had disappeared, and he could not recall where the body was. This is a sign of hallucination, a condition that characters the Dissociative Identity Disorder. The disappearance of the body creates a healthy fear to Leonardo which furthers the situation. The story is therefore based on the disorder that affects the brain and how it operates.

Further analysis shows that when Rachel appeared me from the cave, it becomes difficult to understand how it happens since the prior knowledge of Leonardo was based on the fact that she had disappeared from the island and no one can access the place she went. However, Leonardo does not bother to ask how she reemerges. This gives rise to the question of the memories of the personal identity for the Leonardo. The inability to remain straight to one process is one of the indications. This includes the fact that breaking into ward C is abandoned after discovering that his partner was gone and hence had to look for him in the lighthouse. These are some of the significant signs id the DID and consequently interfered with the ordinary conduct of the investigation.

Dissociative identity disorder is a condition that pushes an individual to poses multiple identities that come about as a result of a severe persistent period of childhood trauma or negligence. There exist many signs and symptoms of the condition. In this case, among the common symptoms include the possession of more than one distinct identity, a severe impairment, and distress in the functioning, disturbances that are not caused by the culture or religious practices. Among other symptoms

However, there are also signs that can easily be observed from an individual suffering from the condition, among the signs include, disagreeing personalities of an individual, each person with its memory social relations and behavioral character. Stress in such individuals causes a sudden transformation in the individual’s personality. These are the significant signs demonstrated by Leonardo, in the movie Shutter Island.

(Video) SHUTTER ISLAND (2010) Ending Explained + Analysis

The movie, Shutter Island also possesses a lot of delusional disorder, especially from the main character Leonardo. These can be seen in many cases where of his action throughout the movie. Without following any order, the f the fact that is partners disappear from the rock, where he saw him before climbing down the cliff make him have a firm belief that he had been taken to a lighthouse. Without any evidence of the disappearance, but rather a current understanding of being born, he switches his investigation to finding his partner on the tower. This firm conviction without proof of truth is a symptom of delusion. It gives an individual a firm idea that something exists while in the real sense, it does not.

A further indication of delusion disorder as shown by Leonardo is the fact that despite the fact that the doctor told him that the lighthouse had been searched and wards C is a secured place. He still insists on accessing it since he firmly believed that Rachel could still be holding in the areas. Therefore, his efforts to prove other the truth make him and his partner make a move to investigate the ward. Moreover, the existence of the mistrust in the side of Daniel is one of the most common cases of delusion. Therefore, the investigation conducted by Daniel and his partner, in the movie about Rachel and other rising cases do not have reliable, facts but rather beliefs on that there might be something that the hospital is hiding.

Dilution disorder is a condition where an individual has fixed beliefs that do not change even if the individual is presented with attached evidence of the nonexistence of the faith. In most cases, the view is referred to as a bizarre, especially when the idea is implausible and peer within the same environment are not in a position to understand them. An example is when an individual believes that he possesses an organ that does not belong to him and the replacement has been done without leaving any scar. In the case of Leonardo’s case, the belief that his wife was killed in a fire set by a local arsonist is one of such instances on t of the bizarre delusion disorder.

There exist different types of delusion disorder that might affect an individual. These include the aromatic where an individual believes that a person that belongs to a higher social class is in love with him. Grandson, on the other hand, is a belief that he or she has a great, talent but others fail to reorganize it. Jealousy, persecutory, somatic and missed dilution is among the common types of disorder that affect an individual. In the case of Leonardo, known as Daniel in the movie, he suffers from persecutory delusion disorder, where he fails to believe what the doctor told him about Rachel, ward C, and the lighthouse.

Different signs and symptoms characterize the delusional disorder. Apart from the unusual symptoms, there may be other bizarre symptoms that happen in real life, but not happening to the individual in question. These people with delusional disorder always function very well in their day to day life only that in the cares of manic cases where hallucination happens may result in the abnormal practices of an individual. These people may express violence due to the high level of anger that they may possess. Therefore, delusional disorder is what pushes Leonardo to investigate everything on the island.

(Video) Shutter Island — Notice The Details

Post-traumatic stress disorder is in of the most presented condition that Daniel suffers from this is a condition that results in experiencing a long time of trauma. In the case of Leonardo, the fever and the constant dream of his wife, especially after her death made him suffer from a long time of trauma, resulting in a post-traumatic stress disorder. One of the places the injury can be seen is where Daniel falls dizzy then dreams of her dead wife and how she died this is a clear indication that he was suffering from their trauma.

Moreover, the presentation of the trauma is the stress to fulfill and find the people responsible for the death of his wife this gives. This gives him an urge to continue investigating crime cases; this is shown by his willingness to research on the end of Rachel children and finds where he hides in the effort to investigate the truth behind her action. The post-traumatic disorder, therefore, interferes with his decision making and exerts a lot of pressure on him to find a solution to the cases of those results from crimes.

The post-traumatic disorder is a mental condition in most cases triggered by terrifying events, which an individual experienced or is expecting to happen. The constant flashback, nightmares and constant severe anxiety including an uncontrollable memory about development are among the typical symptoms of the post-trauma disorder. These people find it difficult to cope or adjust to the new reality. The symptoms may interfere with the day to day operation of an individual in severe cases.

Post-traumatic stress disorder can start within one month of an occurrence, but the symptoms may begin to appear years after the start of the condition. The symptoms hence interfere with the social relations of the individual. It also prevents them from carrying their daily activities. In the movie the main character suffers the past scary memories of the death of the wife, therefore, interfering with his ability to investigate the problem that happens on the on the Shutter Island.

A father analysis of the of the of the post-traumatic stress disorder reveals that the intrusive memories, characterized by recurrent, unwanted and distressing memories of the event, as well as fresh thinking of the traumatic event whenever they occur again. The existence of a severe emotional distress, therefore, prevents one from concentrating and carrying his or her day to day activities in a thorough way. These can be seen in the case of Leonardo.

(Video) Why SHUTTER ISLAND Broke Me

An individual can avoid post stress trauma disorder through avoiding the memories of the past occurs, especially occupying himself with the new exciting thing in a stimulating environment. There is a need to avoid negative thinking or engaging in events that may trigger the memory of an individual to think o0f the past game.

In conclusion, the movie, Shutter Island exploits the psychological factors that affect the mind and the occurrence of disorders. The hospital, therefore, researchers on the control mind activities that may help to cure any chance of the confusion that affects the brain. Leonardo finds himself on their Island, not knowing he also suffers from the condition. This, therefore, gives an opportunity to understand how the disorders may affect an individual way of thinking and operations.

Leonardo Dicaprio of Shutter IslandShutter Island Movie SummaryShutter Island PsychoanalysisShutter Island Psychological ExplanationShutter Island Psychology Essay

FAQs

Was Andrew faking it at the end of Shutter Island? ›

Only Teddy is not a real person but a delusion created by inmate Andrew Laeddis. The ending of “Shutter Island” reveals that DiCaprio's character is a patient himself, committed to the Shutter Island facility after murdering his wife (Michelle Williams) because she went insane and killed their children.

Is Teddy actually Andrew? ›

As revealed in the lighthouse, Teddy (DiCaprio) is actually Andrew. In reality, it was his wife, Dolores (who was herself a depressed woman) that murdered their three children by drowning them. She had earlier set fire to their apartment in the city.

Did Teddy get lobotomized? ›

Teddy Daniels would never have gone with them willingly, proving once again that he chose to go along with the lobotomy by choice and was of sound mind at the time.

What was the point of the experiment in Shutter Island? ›

The "investigation" was an attempt by Cawley to break Teddy out of his funk, get him to accept reality, and deal with his issues. The whole island was in on this elaborate hoax. And Chuck is still alive, but he's actually Dr. Lester Sheehan.

Did Andrew get lobotomized on purpose? ›

His unusual treatment's made him aware of the terrible thing he's done: guilt has therefore engulfed him, and he's deliberately getting himself lobotomised to escape it.

Who Teddy really was in Shutter Island? ›

Cawley explains that Teddy is in fact Andrew Laeddis, the most dangerous patient in Ward C. Teddy/Andrew was incarcerated on the island after he murdered his manic depressive wife Dolores, who drowned their three children.

Is Leo actually crazy in Shutter Island? ›

The general consensus is that the films ending proves that he was insane the entire time and that's pretty much it.

What is the law of 4 in Shutter Island mean? ›

What does "The Law of 4" from the note found in Rachel's room mean? Dr Cawley (Ben Kingsley) explains that the "Law of 4" refers to the fact that two names are anagrams. They are: (1) Dolores Chanal (Andrew's wife's maiden name) rearranged to Rachel Solando and (2) Andrew Laeddis rearranged to Edward Daniels.

What mental illness does Teddy have in Shutter Island? ›

However, in a radical twist, we find that Teddy is himself a patient at the asylum. He suffers from Delusional Disorder, creating a false world to escape the dark reality of his past. Shutter Island is one of the many films that present the ethical considerations of psychological treatment to a mainstream audience.

Who killed children Shutter Island? ›

Cawley tells Teddy that he himself is in fact Andrew Laeddis (an anagram of Edward Daniels) and that he has been a patient at Shutter Island for two years for murdering his wife, Dolores Chanal (an anagram of Rachel Solando), after she murdered their three children.

Who is the lady in the cave in Shutter Island? ›

Inside the fire-lit cave, Teddy finds a middle-aged woman wielding a knife. He asks her to put down the knife and quickly assumes that she is the "real" Rachel Solando. Rachel explains that she used to work at Ashecliffe as a doctor before being admitted as a patient.

Does Teddy have schizophrenia? ›

This research discussed about schizophrenia symptoms in Teddy alias Andrew Laedis that was acute and dangerous and also discussed the psychodrama treatment for Andrew. The main character is described to have a dangerous illness which is schizophrenia due to get from his traumatic events in world of war.

Why was the cup empty in Shutter Island? ›

DiCaprio's character is part of a role-playing experiment to help him overcome repressed memories, which is why the glass appears to be invisible. From Teddy's perspective, he blocks out the water because it reminds him of a traumatic experience.

Why did the lady tell Teddy to run in Shutter Island? ›

Mrs. Kearns writes "run" on the paper she slips to Teddy because she knows he has an opportunity to escape while they're doing the whole role play experiment. It's also why she sounds "coached" about what to tell Teddy - she has been.

What does the water represent in Shutter Island? ›

Water, on the other hand, represents the reality of what happened to his wife and children. This is why Andrew/Teddy has a consistent aversion to water throughout the film. Using cinematography in subtle ways, these symbols are present throughout the film to allude to the fact that Teddy is living in a dream world.

What mental illness did lobotomy treat? ›

Introduced in the mid-20th century, lobotomies have always been controversial, but were widely performed for more than two decades as treatment for schizophrenia, manic depression and bipolar disorder, among other mental illnesses.

What happened to Teddy at the end of Shutter Island? ›

Teddy is Andrew Laeddis, a demented killer and a patient in the mental hospital he's “investigating.” His psychiatrist has encouraged Andrew to act out his delusions. However, this fails, and Andrew returns to his psychotic state. The film ends with him being taken to be lobotomized.

Why did Freeman do lobotomies? ›

His new "leucotomy" procedure, intended to treat mental illness, took small corings of the patient's frontal lobes. Moniz became a mentor and idol for Freeman who modified the procedure and renamed it the "lobotomy".

Who is the crazy one in Shutter Island? ›

Ward C – George Noyce in Shutter Island Explained

One of the patients talks to Edward. Initially, Edward thinks it is Laeddis, but it turns out to be Noyce. Noyce is a Ward C level crazy person. Over the past two years, Andrew has filled his head with conspiracy theories about what goes on inside the lighthouse.

Was Teddy crazy at the end of Shutter Island? ›

Yes, he is. All you saw before the lighthouse scene was a role play by his psychiatrist. Teddy's real name was Andrew Laeddis, and he was the 67th patients, the most dangerous patient in the facility.

Did Leo actually cut his hand? ›

In a big monologue from this character, he cut his hand and filmed the whole thing while bleeding profusely. As DiCaprio recalled to The Hollywood Reporter, while cutting himself obviously hurt, it gave the scene a particular edge it didn't have before. “My hand started really pouring blood all over the table.

Why does Teddy wear a plaster in Shutter Island? ›

The Band aid symbolises his 'sickness" and taking it off symbolises the fact that he's cured.

What mental illness does Jasmine have? ›

During her stay with Ginger, Jasmine also deals with her anxiety-depressive disorder. She easily gets nervous of with panic attacks, and he constantly has thoughts about her past life and the personal betrayals she faced then. When Jasmine reflects on her past life, she ussualy can't helo but to madly talk alone.

Is Shutter Island a hallucination? ›

Shutter Island is a film that shows so many evidences of hallucination experienced by the main character, Teddy Daniels. Teddy Daniels had bad experiences in the past which lead him to change his identity in order to forget his past.

What did the wife do to the kids in Shutter Island? ›

Plot. In 1954, U.S. Marshal Edward "Teddy" Daniels and his new partner Chuck Aule travel to Ashecliffe Hospital for the criminally insane on Shutter Island, Boston Harbor to investigate the disappearance of Rachel Solando, who drowned her three children.

Why did Teddy call her daughter Allison? ›

In the Season 15 finale, Teddy gives birth to her and Owen's daughter, whom they both have named Allison, in honor of Teddy's best-friend Allison Brown, who died during 9/11.

Who is the father of Teddy's baby? ›

Allison Hunt is the daughter of Owen Hunt and Teddy Altman.

What mental illness does Theodore? ›

The main character named Theodore Finch diagnosed bipolar disorder as shown by his experienced manic and depressive period. Secondly, the researcher found the causes of bipolar disorder reflected in All the Bright Places because of the problems in his family.

What mental illness does Andrew have in Shutter Island? ›

This research discussed about schizophrenia symptoms in Teddy alias Andrew Laedis that was acute and dangerous and also discussed the psychodrama treatment for Andrew. The main character is described to have a dangerous illness which is schizophrenia due to get from his traumatic events in world of war.

Does Shutter Island have two endings? ›

It's a movie about an isolated psychiatric hospital; they can only have two possible twist endings, that the asylum has been taken over by the patients, or The Other One.

Why does the woman write run on Teddy's notepad? ›

Kearns writes "run" on the paper she slips to Teddy because she knows he has an opportunity to escape while they're doing the whole role play experiment. It's also why she sounds "coached" about what to tell Teddy - she has been.

Did he get lobotomized in Shutter Island? ›

However, this fails, and Andrew returns to his psychotic state. The film ends with him being taken to be lobotomized. As the film ends, Andrew utters a line that's nowhere to be found in the original book. “This place makes me wonder, which would be worse,” he says.

Why does the woman shush Teddy in Shutter Island? ›

The creepy old lady does the shush sign to Teddy because the doctors had told everyone in the hospital about the experiment they are conducting with Teddy, and that they are not supposed to say anything to him about it. The lady is mentally ill and she was telling Teddy to be quiet, in essence not to spoil the secret.

Why did the glass of water disappear in Shutter Island? ›

DiCaprio's character is part of a role-playing experiment to help him overcome repressed memories, which is why the glass appears to be invisible. From Teddy's perspective, he blocks out the water because it reminds him of a traumatic experience.

Who is the missing person in Shutter Island? ›

In 1954, U.S. Marshal Edward "Teddy" Daniels and his new partner Chuck Aule travel to Ashecliffe Hospital for the criminally insane on Shutter Island, Boston Harbor to investigate the disappearance of Rachel Solando, who drowned her three children.

Videos

1. A Detective Uncovers the Truth About the Mysterious Island. Shutter Island Explained
(RED RECAPS)
2. The Big Clue Everyone Missed Early In Shutter Island
(Looper)
3. Shutter Island: Is It Deep or Dumb? (Leonardo DiCaprio) – Wisecrack Edition
(Wisecrack)
4. Psychiatrist Breaks Down Psychotic Episodes In Movies | GQ
(GQ)
5. SHUTTER ISLAND - The missing glass phenomenon (Video Essay)
(Sundays at the Cinema)
6. Shutter Island Explained | Classic Explained Episode 17
(Lucas Blue)

Top Articles

Latest Posts

Article information

Author: Amb. Frankie Simonis

Last Updated: 12/07/2022

Views: 6111

Rating: 4.6 / 5 (76 voted)

Reviews: 91% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Amb. Frankie Simonis

Birthday: 1998-02-19

Address: 64841 Delmar Isle, North Wiley, OR 74073

Phone: +17844167847676

Job: Forward IT Agent

Hobby: LARPing, Kitesurfing, Sewing, Digital arts, Sand art, Gardening, Dance

Introduction: My name is Amb. Frankie Simonis, I am a hilarious, enchanting, energetic, cooperative, innocent, cute, joyous person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.